Interested in more careers-related content? Check out our new weekly Work Life newsletter. Sent every Monday afternoon.
THE QUESTION
I’ve been job hunting for more than a year and it’s been a frustrating process. I’ve been hearing through my network that a few jobs I’ve applied for ended up going to internal candidates, which they likely knew about before the job posting went up. Is there a way to know if a job posting is just satisfying requirements for the organization when they have an internal candidate they’re going to hire anyway? Any telltale signs to look out for? I’m hoping this will help me streamline my application strategy and avoid putting time and effort into job applications that I don’t even have a chance at getting.
THE FIRST ANSWER
Carl Casis, founder and recruiter, Casis Careers, Toronto
Some organizations might post a job even though they already have an internal candidate in mind. It is usually a compliance or policy requirement and there is no way to know for certain.
That said, do not rule yourself out too quickly. Job descriptions are often “wish lists” and internal candidates do not always get the role. If you meet most of the requirements and can learn the rest, apply. Let the hiring team decide. You may even bring strengths that the internal applicant does not and good recruiters will do the work to make sure every qualified candidate is considered. If they do not, that is a signal in itself. It may not be the kind of organization you want to join.
The key is where you spend your effort. Focus on quality over quantity. Ten thoughtful, tailored applications will take you further than blasting out 100 résumés. Whenever possible, apply directly through the company site instead of only through job boards, because those applications are more visible to recruiters. And above all, remember that most hiring still comes from connections. Treat your search like building a pipeline: target companies you care about, keep consistent outreach and look for referrals. Just do not get emotionally attached to any single posting. Sometimes the outcome is already decided and it is outside your control.
Even if a posting turns out to be a formality, the effort is not wasted. Each application sharpens your materials and keeps you active in the market. The real edge comes from combining smart applications with relationship building outside the posting process.
THE SECOND ANSWER
Carine Lacroix, founder and chief executive officer, Reneshone, Oakville
A year-long job hunt, clouded by whispers of internal hires, tests even the most determined job seekers. With discernment, you can cut through this fog, using defensive and offensive tactics to turn frustration into progress. In Canada, internal hiring is a common, legal practice that bolsters retention, yet policy-driven postings – ads created to meet procedural requirements while favouring an internal candidate – can derail your efforts. Watch for these potential red flags in job postings:
Vague descriptions: Listings with generic duties such as “manage tasks” or “support team operations” without clear goals may mask a procedural step, reflect a new role’s unclear scope or favour an internal hire.
Brief posting windows: Roles open for three to five days may signal a pre-selected internal candidate.
Recycled ads: Jobs reappearing every few months with minor tweaks may reflect turnover or a formality to collect external applications while favouring a pre-selected internal candidate.
Tailored requirements: Hyper-specific criteria, such as “10+ years in oilsands engineering plus AI expertise”, may fit an internal candidate’s profile.
Swift rejections: Instant auto-rejects or no response may suggest a fixed outcome.
You can also optimize the likelihood of sealing a job with offensive, proactive moves in Canada’s competitive market. Networking drives 70 per cent of opportunities, so connect purposefully on LinkedIn with recruiters, leverage alumni networks for valuable insights and target mid-sized firms where internal barriers are often lower. Harness job boards such as Indeed or Eluta, filtering for recent postings to capture fresh roles. With vigilance and bold outreach, you’ll sharpen your edge and boost your chances of landing the right opportunity.
Have a question for our experts? Send an email to NineToFive@globeandmail.com with ‘Nine to Five’ in the subject line. Emails without the correct subject line may not be answered.