Jeremy Skibicki is shown in this undated handout photo, taken by police while in custody, provided by the Court of King's Bench.HO/The Canadian Press
The only evidence police have pointing to the identity of one victim of an admitted serial killer is a bit of DNA found on a jacket cuff, a Winnipeg judge heard Tuesday.
A forensics expert testified that multiple portions of a reversible jacket from designer Baby Phat were analyzed.
Police believe the DNA belonged to the unidentified victim Indigenous leaders have since named Mashkode Bizhiki’ikwe, or Buffalo Woman.
“It was female in origin,” Florence Celestin testified remotely from Ottawa, where she is based, at the trial of Jeremy Skibicki.
Ms. Celestin, who works at the RCMP’s forensics laboratory, told court more than 100 exhibits taken from Mr. Skibicki’s home have been processed up until earlier this year in attempts to identify Buffalo Woman.
The only sample she was able to extract and the only one believed to belong to Buffalo Woman came from the cuff of the jacket.
Ms. Celestin said she’s not able to confirm whether a person is alive or dead based off a DNA sample.
Investigators believe Buffalo Woman is an Indigenous woman in her mid-20s who was killed around March 15, 2022.
The Crown has said Mr. Skibicki forcibly confined Buffalo Woman, choked and then drowned her. It is not known where her remains are.
Mr. Skibicki told police he sold the Baby Phat jacket belonging to her on Facebook Marketplace.
Police were later able to track it down.
Mr. Skibicki, 37, is charged with first-degree murder for the slayings of Buffalo Woman and three others – Rebecca Contois, 24, Morgan Harris, 39, and Marcedes Myran, 26.
His lawyers have said he killed the four Indigenous women but is not criminally responsible owing to mental illness.
Crown prosecutors say the killings were racially motivated and Mr. Skibicki preyed on the vulnerable women at homeless shelters. He assaulted the women, strangled or drowned them and disposed of their bodies in garbage bins. Two were dismembered.
They previously presented video surveillance evidence of Mr. Skibicki with the three identified victims to paint a complete picture of the investigation into Mr. Skibicki’s actions.
Video evidence of him with Ms. Contois has not been played in court, as police originally arrested Mr. Skibicki after her partial remains were found in a garbage bin on May 16, 2022.
Court has heard police collected about a dozen unknown female DNA samples from Mr. Skibicki’s home.
Ms. Celestin said nothing else collected from Mr. Skibicki’s home matched the sample found on the Baby Phat jacket.
In early 2023, police collected samples from the father and mother of Ashlee Shingoose, a First Nations woman who was last seen in downtown Winnipeg in March 2022, Crown prosecutor Chris Vanderhooft told court.
A sample from Ms. Shingoose was sent in February of this year to gather more definitive information. It was determined Ms. Shingoose’s DNA was found on a cigarette butt collected from Mr. Skibicki’s home, but was not a match for the sample from the jacket.
The Crown has not proposed Mr. Skibicki killed Ms. Shingoose and does not believe there are additional victims.
Police still consider her missing.
Court also heard Mr. Skibicki was unable to identify Ms. Myran to police. In September, 2022, her family reported her missing.
Police collected DNA from Ms. Myran’s mother and in November of that year Ms. Celestin was able to confirm it was a match to samples taken from Mr. Skibicki’s home that belong to Ms. Myran.
Also Tuesday, the Crown requested Mr. Skibicki undergo a mental health assessment.
Mr. Vanderhooft told Chief Justice Glenn Joyal the prosecutors requested an assessment to gather additional information after defence lawyers submitted their own expert opinion along with Mr. Skibicki’s medical records.
Mr. Skibicki’s lawyers opposed the motion saying it was not in the best interest of their client.
“I have a report available for the court,” Leonard Tailleur said referencing the mental health assessment obtained by the defence.
Chief Justice Joyal said that was not enough of a reason and sided with the Crown ordering the assessment take place this weekend.
The federal government has a support line for those affected by the issue of missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls: 1-844-413-6649. The Hope for Wellness Helpline, with support in Cree, Ojibway and Inuktitut, is also available to all Indigenous people in Canada: 1-855-242-3310.