Unum Group Earnings Call: Growth Intact, Volatility Rising
Unum Group ((UNM)) has held its Q4 earnings call. Read on for the main highlights of the call.
Claim 50% Off TipRanks Premium
- Unlock hedge fund-level data and powerful investing tools for smarter, sharper decisions
- Stay ahead of the market with the latest news and analysis and maximize your portfolio's potential
Unum Group Balances Earnings Pressure with Confident 2026 Growth Plan
Unum Group’s latest earnings call struck a cautiously positive tone, as management balanced solid top-line growth, strong capital strength, and clear progress on long-term care risk reduction against a notable earnings miss and margin volatility, particularly in group disability and some international lines. While profitability fell short of expectations for the year, executives emphasized resilient core returns, healthy sales momentum in key businesses, and a constructive outlook for 2026, framing recent bumps as manageable within a fundamentally strong franchise.
Core Premium Growth Holds Firm Despite Earnings Miss
Core operations remained a bright spot, with premiums growing roughly 4.5% on a constant-currency basis excluding transaction impacts. Reported core premium rose 3.7% for the full year and 2.9% in the fourth quarter, supported by steady demand across Unum’s U.S., Colonial, and international businesses. Core sales finished the year up 1.1%, and management sees that accelerating to 4%–7% premium growth by 2026. For investors, the message is that underlying business volume is moving in the right direction even as near-term claims experience weighs on earnings.
Colonial and International Lead Top-Line Momentum
Colonial Life and Unum International stood out as growth engines. Colonial Life delivered a 10% sales increase in the fourth quarter and 5.3% growth for the full year, with full-year premium up 3.1% to $1.8 billion. International premiums climbed even faster, rising 11.5% in Q4 and 10% for the year to $1.1 billion. This strong top-line performance abroad and in the voluntary benefits space underscores customer demand for workplace protection products and gives Unum diversified growth outside its more mature U.S. group benefits book.
Core Operations Generate High Returns on Equity
Despite the headline earnings miss, Unum’s core businesses continued to generate robust returns. Adjusted return on equity from core operations hovered around 20% for both the quarter and full year, a key indicator that the core underwriting engine remains highly profitable over the cycle. Looking ahead to 2026, management is targeting mid-20s ROE for Unum US and more than 25% ROE in group disability, assuming benefit ratios normalize within a 62%–64% range. This signals confidence that current loss ratio pressure is cyclical rather than structural.
Capital Strength Underpins Aggressive Shareholder Returns
The balance sheet remains a core pillar of the investment case. Year-end statutory capital stood at about 440% risk-based capital, with $3.2 billion of cash at the holding company. Leveraging this strong capital base, Unum returned roughly all of its free cash flow to shareholders in the past year, repurchasing about $1 billion of stock and increasing its dividend by 10% for 2025. The company plans to repeat that playbook in 2026 with another ~$1 billion in buybacks and a further 10% dividend hike, signaling confidence in its long-term earnings power and capital generation.
Long-Term Care De-Risking Takes a Big Step Forward
Management highlighted substantial progress on de-risking its closed long-term care block, historically a key overhang for the stock. Unum completed a reinsurance transaction that ceded roughly 20% of LTC reserves and executed an internal reinsurance action, together expected to reduce LTC reserves by more than $4 billion in 2025. The company also removed morbidity and mortality improvement assumptions and has stopped offering new employee coverage on existing group LTC cases, effectively putting the block into full runoff. These moves aim to stabilize a legacy book that has been a major source of uncertainty, even as management acknowledged that some volatility remains.
Digital Adoption Supports Strong Persistency
Unum is leaning on technology to deepen customer engagement and improve persistency. More than one-third of core premium is now associated with customers using the company’s digital platforms such as HR Connect, Broker Connect, and MyUnum. Persistency remains high overall, with U.S. Group persistency at 90.2%. Importantly, clients using HR Connect show 2%–4% higher persistency, supporting a more predictable revenue base and lower acquisition costs over time. For investors, rising digital adoption is an under-the-radar driver of margin stability and growth.
Alternative Portfolio Shows Recovery but Still Below Target
The alternative investment portfolio, largely backing the LTC block, showed improving performance but has not fully reached management’s long-term targets. The portfolio generated $25.9 million of income in the fourth quarter, translating into a 7.6% annualized return for the quarter and a 6.4% yield for the full year. While this represents clear progress versus earlier-period levels, it remains shy of the company’s stated long-term expectation of 8%–10%. Investment income remains a swing factor for earnings, particularly given its linkage to closed-block performance.
Earnings, Statutory Results, and Segment Profitability Under Pressure
Unum’s full-year adjusted EPS came in at $8.13, below management’s prior expectations, with after-tax adjusted operating earnings totaling $1.4 billion and statutory earnings of $1.1 billion versus a prior range of $1.3 billion–$1.6 billion. Segment-level results reflected this pressure: Unum US before-tax adjusted operating income declined 13.1% year over year in the fourth quarter and 11.6% for the full year. International underlying earnings fell 11.7% in Q4 and 3.5% for the year, primarily on unfavorable UK group disability claims, while Colonial Life posted a 7.2% AOI decline in Q4 and a modest 0.7% drop for the year. The message to the market is that, while growth is intact, earnings quality has encountered a tougher claims environment.
Group Disability Loss Ratios Normalize with Added Volatility
Group disability, a key earnings driver, is transitioning from unusually strong to more normal profitability, introducing volatility along the way. The Unum US group disability benefit ratio rose to 64.2% in Q4 and 62.4% for the full year, up from a historically low 59% in the prior year. As a result, group disability adjusted operating income declined 22.8% to $479.8 million for the full year, with Q4 earnings down versus the prior year. Management framed these shifts as part of a normalization process from exceptionally favorable conditions, but the speed and variability of the move are pressuring near-term results.
Supplemental & Voluntary Earnings Hit by Higher Claims
Supplemental and voluntary products, another growth and margin pillar, also felt pressure. Adjusted operating income in this segment declined 8.2% in the fourth quarter to $95.5 million and was flat for the full year at $472.7 million. The quarter’s weaker performance was driven by higher benefits experience across multiple product lines, which weighed on profitability even as overall demand remains solid. Investors will be watching whether benefit ratios in this business stabilize in line with management’s future targets.
Corporate Costs Remain Elevated Amid Investment in Technology
Corporate-level expenses continue to run high as Unum invests in staffing and IT infrastructure. The corporate segment posted a $51.1 million loss in the fourth quarter and a $171.6 million loss for the full year, though this was an improvement versus a $191.2 million loss in the prior year. Management is clearly spending to support digital initiatives and operational modernization, which should aid long-term efficiency, but near term it adds another layer of drag on reported earnings.
Closed Block Still Volatile, Highlighting Legacy Risk
Despite substantial de-risking progress, the Closed Block—dominated by LTC—continues to exhibit earnings volatility. It produced modest adjusted operating income of $21.1 million in Q4 and $63.5 million for the year, with the LTC net premium ratio remaining elevated at 97.5% in the fourth quarter. Reflecting the unpredictable nature of this business, Unum will move Closed Block earnings below the line starting in 2026, effectively separating core business performance from legacy noise in reported adjusted operating results. This change is designed to give investors a clearer view of core earnings while acknowledging the ongoing risk profile of the closed block.
Specific Q4 Loss Drivers Highlight Short-Term Noise
Management pointed to specific, somewhat technical factors behind elevated Q4 loss ratios in group disability. The quarter saw a lower average size of recoveries, roughly 5% below expectations, and unusually low claimant mortality, about 10% below expected levels. These dynamics contributed to quarter-to-quarter benefit ratio volatility and underscore how small shifts in recoveries and mortality can materially move reported margins in disability. While management views these as episodic rather than structural, they add uncertainty to near-term earnings predictability.
Guidance: Solid 2026 Outlook with Strong Cash Generation
Looking ahead, Unum laid out a constructive 2026 roadmap. The company projects core premium growth of 4%–7% (with Unum US at 4%–6%), building from about 3.7% reported core premium growth in 2025 and a roughly 4.5% adjusted growth rate. Adjusted after-tax operating EPS is guided to $8.60–$8.90 in 2026, representing about 8%–12% growth off a redefined 2025 base of $7.93. Management targets core ROE of around 20% in 2025, with group disability ROE exceeding 25% at a 62%–64% benefit ratio and not expecting ratios above 65%. Segment targets include high-teens ROE and 48%–50% benefit ratios at Colonial, a 70%–72% benefit ratio in International, and $120–$130 million in quarterly earnings from supplemental and voluntary lines with benefit ratios also at 48%–50%. The company aims for an overall expense ratio near 22% and corporate losses of about $50 million per quarter. Capital generation is projected at $1.4 billion–$1.6 billion (statutory earnings of $1.2 billion–$1.4 billion), driving free cash flow of $1.2 billion–$1.4 billion. Unum plans about $1 billion in share repurchases and a 10% dividend increase, deploying roughly all free cash flow while still targeting year-end RBC of 400%–425%, holding company liquidity of $2.0–$2.5 billion, and leverage below 25%. Beginning in 2026, Closed Block results will be excluded from adjusted operating earnings, while completed LTC reserve reductions and improving alternative portfolio yields (7.6% in Q4 versus a long-term goal of 8%–10%) are expected to gradually improve the risk profile.
In summary, Unum’s earnings call laid out a story of a well-capitalized insurer navigating a bumpier claims environment while staying committed to growth, de-risking, and generous capital returns. Core businesses are expanding, returns on equity remain high, and the company is aggressively addressing legacy long-term care risks. At the same time, elevated benefit ratios, earnings volatility, and segment-level profit declines remind investors that the near term will not be smooth. For equity holders, the setup is one of solid fundamentals and attractive capital deployment, tempered by the need to watch execution on claims normalization and investment performance over the next several quarters.
